The Milburn Review sets out an ambitious vision for increasing young people’s participation and achievement through apprenticeships. Greater flexibility and accessibility within vocational education is welcome, but it must not come at the expense of assessment rigour, consistency or employer confidence.
The ambition to significantly increase apprenticeship participation and completions will only succeed if the qualifications and assessments underpinning them remain credible. It will also create a significant delivery challenge for a sector already adapting to major apprenticeship reforms.
Assessment is changing. Rather than everything being concentrated in a high-stakes assessment at the end of an apprenticeship, the new model creates opportunities for assessment to take place at different points throughout the learner journey, including greater involvement from training providers and colleges with appropriate oversight from awarding organisations.
At Innovate Awarding, we see significant potential in this approach. We have already developed our Blended Assessment model in response to the reforms, with the processes and policies in place to support providers as the new approach develops.
But greater flexibility brings an important challenge. Apprentices may be assessed in different ways and at different stages, but they must continue to be judged consistently against the same outcomes.
Assessment can be flexible in its delivery, but it must remain consistent in its expectations.
As apprenticeship numbers grow, independent quality assurance, standardisation and robust assessment decisions will therefore become even more important. Ultimately, employers must be able to trust what a successful apprenticeship tells them about an individual’s skills and occupational competence.
Increasing participation will also require the sector to think differently about assessment capacity. Training providers, colleges and employers all have a role to play, while technology can help the sector deliver assessment more efficiently and at greater scale without compromising quality.
That includes being open minded about the potential role of AI and wider adoption of technology that can support the assessment system, not undermine confidence in how decisions are made.
The Milburn Review is also right to focus on improving apprenticeship achievement. But higher achievement must come through better preparation, support and the removal of barriers to success, rather than lowering the threshold for occupational competence.
We need to remove barriers, not lower the bar for success. Those are two very different things.
Rob May, Managing Director at Innovate Awarding, said:
“Having reflected on what I’ve seen and read over the past couple of hours, my initial position is that greater flexibility and accessibility in the vocational education system is welcome, but it must not come at the expense of assessment rigour, consistency or employer confidence.
"Milburn’s ambitions for participation, progression and achievement, including doubling young apprenticeships by 2036, will only succeed if the qualifications underpinning them remain credible. It is also important to recognise the scale of the delivery challenge this creates. The awarding and assessment sector is already undertaking a major programme of reform, reconfiguring apprenticeship assessments for the new model. A substantial increase in apprenticeship numbers will inevitably mean a substantial increase in assessment capacity that is needed too.
“The review’s support for modular assessment, practical demonstrations and potentially greater employer involvement in assessment aligns with the direction of apprenticeship reform, and Innovate’s ‘Blended Assessment’ proposition and modular pathways such as our Care Standard Plus offer. As assessment volumes grow, we will need to think differently about how colleges, training providers, employers and technology can support delivery while awarding organisations retain oversight of moderation, standardisation and quality. This also reflects Innovate’s existing approach to blended assessment, where elements of assessment can be delivered during training with external quality assurance and oversight retained.
“But flexibility creates an important challenge: how do we ensure apprentices are consistently judged against the same standard and assessed against the same outcomes? Assessment can be flexible in its delivery, but it must remain consistent in its expectations. If flexibility results in people being assessed against different expectations or under significantly different conditions, we risk undermining public confidence and, crucially, employer trust in what an apprenticeship achievement actually represents.
“Milburn’s ambition to double youth apprenticeship achievements is substantial. It will inevitably place pressure on the system to deliver more assessments, potentially in more flexible ways. Independent quality assurance, standardisation and robust assessment decisions will therefore become more important. The credibility of apprenticeships ultimately rests on employers being able to trust what a successful assessment tells them.
“We should also be open minded about the role technology, including AI, could play in helping the system meet that increased demand. This should not mean handing assessment decisions wholesale to AI. Human oversight must remain central. But under controlled conditions, there is an important conversation to be had about how AI can be used reliably and safely to support assessment delivery at greater scale.” “Milburn also proposes increasing apprenticeship achievement rates from around 65% to 80%. That is a welcome ambition, but it must be achieved through better preparation and support rather than lowering the threshold for occupational competence. The real measure of success is not how many young people enter apprenticeships, but how many leave genuinely competent and ready for work. The drive for higher completion rates must not compromise public confidence.
“Milburn is right to challenge the system to improve apprenticeship achievement rates. But the answer is to remove barriers to success, not lower the bar for success. Those are two very different things.”